“Who keeps the house?” is usually the first question people ask when a relationship ends, and often the hardest one to say out loud. The home is likely to be your biggest asset. It is also where your children sleep, where your routines are, and where your life has been built.

The short answer is that nobody keeps the house automatically. This guide explains how it is worked out, what your options are, and what to sort out with your lender, so that you can plan with a clear head.

Three Assumptions That Are Not Rules

People often assume that one of these decides it. None of them do:

  • “It is in my name, so it is mine.” The home is part of the property pool whoever is on the title, whether it is in joint names or one name.
  • “I pay the mortgage, so I keep it.” Financial contributions count, but so do non-financial ones, such as raising children and running the household.
  • “The parent with the children keeps the house.” The children’s care and housing needs are considered, but there is no rule that one parent keeps the home.

Instead, the Family Law Act sets out how property is divided. The Court looks at what you own and owe, what each of you has contributed, each person’s current and future circumstances (including the care and housing needs of any children), and whether the outcome is just and equitable in all the circumstances. Couples negotiating outside court are expected to follow the same approach. The Attorney-General’s Department fact sheet explains it in plain English.

Four Ways It Can Work

  • One of you buys the other out. The person keeping the home pays the other their share, usually by refinancing the loan. This is the most common route when one person wants to stay and can afford to.
  • One of you keeps the home and the other takes more of something else. For example, a larger share of superannuation or savings, so that no cash changes hands.
  • You stay co-owners for a while. Some couples agree to keep the home in joint names for a set period, for example until the children finish school. It can work, but it ties you together financially, so the terms need to be clear.
  • You sell and divide the proceeds. If neither of you can afford to keep the home, or you would both prefer a fresh start, selling is often the simplest way to finish.

If you decide to sell, our selling property team can look after the sale.

What Your Lender Needs to Agree

A settlement between the two of you does not bind your lender. If the loan is in joint names, each of you can remain liable for the whole debt, and neither of you is released until the lender agrees.

If you want to keep the home, the lender will look at whether you can afford the loan on your own, and may require you to refinance. It helps to speak to your lender or a broker early, before you agree to terms you may not be able to finance.

Can You Afford to Keep It?

It is worth answering these questions before you commit to keeping the home:

  • What is the home worth now? A valuation gives you a figure to work from.
  • How much would you need to borrow to buy the other person out?
  • Could you meet the repayments, rates, insurance and maintenance on your own income?
  • What else is in the property pool, and could it be used to balance the settlement?
  • Would a smaller home, or selling, give you more security?

Staying on the Mortgage After You Separate

Remaining on a joint loan after you separate carries real risk, even when the relationship is friendly. You can stay liable for the debt if the other person falls behind. It can also limit what you can borrow for a new home. If you plan to stay on the mortgage for a time, we recommend putting the arrangement in writing and having a clear plan for when you will be released.

Putting It in Writing

An agreement about the house is only as strong as the paperwork behind it. An agreement you have only signed between yourselves is not a court order. Most couples make theirs binding through consent orders or a binding financial agreement.

Then the transfer, and the mortgage release, need to be done properly. Transfers between separating partners under a court order or binding financial agreement may be exempt from NSW transfer duty, subject to conditions, as Revenue NSW explains. A capital gains tax rollover may also apply, and the Australian Taxation Office sets out the conditions. Our conveyancing team handles transfers, so the legal and property sides are managed together. We also recommend you speak to your accountant.

There are time limits too. If you were married, an application for property orders should generally be made within 12 months of your divorce order taking effect. If you were in a de facto relationship, it is two years from the end of the relationship. If you separated some time ago, check your dates early.

Frequently Asked Questions About Keeping the House in NSW

Who keeps the house in a separation?

Nobody keeps it automatically. The home is part of the property pool, and the outcome depends on what you own and owe, your contributions, your current and future circumstances, and what is just and equitable. Many couples agree between themselves, and one of them often buys the other out.

Does the name on the title decide who keeps the house?

No. The home is part of the property pool whether it is in joint names or one name. The name on the title matters for the paperwork, but it does not decide who keeps the property.

Can my ex stay on the mortgage if I keep the house?

Only if the lender agrees. If both names stay on the loan, each of you can remain liable for the debt, so most settlements remove one person through a refinance. Speak to your lender early about what it needs.

Do I have to sell the house?

Not necessarily. Some people buy the other person out, some keep the home and take less of other assets, and some stay co-owners for a set time. Selling is the simplest option if neither of you can afford to keep it.

Will I pay stamp duty if the house is transferred to me?

Transfers between separating partners under a court order or a binding financial agreement may be exempt from NSW transfer duty, subject to conditions. Your solicitor or conveyancer can confirm whether the exemption applies to your transfer.

What if we have already agreed informally who keeps the house?

An informal agreement is not a court order, and your lender is not bound by it. It is worth having it made binding, and the transfer and mortgage release properly completed, so that nothing is left uncertain.

Talk to Us Before You Decide

There is no single right answer to who keeps the house, and the best outcome depends on your finances, your children and your plans. If you are in Maitland or the wider Hunter, we can meet you at our High Street office, or by phone or video. To find out more, see our property settlement page, or our family law team.

Book a consultation with our team today, or call us on (02) 4933 5111. Check our FAQ page if you have any questions.

Share this article:
Related articles